Brock Silvey and the Case of the Zombie Proposals

by | Jun 5, 2023 | Learning Edge Blog, News

Jennifer Filla

Zombie proposals are a thing, not just at Northwestern University, but everywhere! A zombie proposal is when you have submitted a major gift proposal to a donor prospect, but there has been no movement since the ask. There has not been a “no,” “maybe,” and certainly not a “yes.” There is no movement.

We might speculate on all sorts of reasons a major gift proposal might turn into a zombie. But as Brock Silvey points out, behind every zombie proposal is a relationship between a gift officer and a donor prospect that is human, real, and needs to be respected.

So, if you’re not going to simply bury the zombies, what should you do?

Apparently, you should communicate better and more frequently.

It always feels like a let-down when data analysis reveals a truth that once spoken sounds exactly like common sense – except that no-one had the sense to say it before the data analysis!

Follow the trail of prospect management clues and find out the tactics Brock has been using to help the gift officers he works with to close their zombie proposals.

Resources Mentioned

How One University Used Data to Eliminate ‘Zombie Proposals’ and Improve Big-Gift Fundraising | by David Lively and Brijesh Jani | The Chronicle of Philanthropy | Feb 2023

Words from happy Researchers

Success Stories

I love your Master Class format – small group, clearly defined curriculum, solid professional information and resources and focus on discussion.  But most importantly I was impressed and delighted to see that you incorporated an additional and extremely practical layer of knowledge, through hands on experience with tools (pivot tables) or resources (Candid).  This adds real value to the educational experience you offer.

Betsy Mehlman

2020-Master Class

Jen’s course on insider stock and compensation was informative, interesting, and well-thought out. Jen broke down the complicated material into digestible pieces. She showed us resources that I use in my day-to-day research that I wouldn’t have otherwise known about. Jen is always quick to respond and has been helpful even after the class has ended. She answers questions thoroughly and is always pleasant.

I was able to take what I learned from the course and present the material to our front-line fundraisers. One fundraiser told me after my presentation that she discovered one of her donor’s compensation was much higher than she thought. So, already, this information has come in handy! Thanks again Jen!

Kim Anthony, San Francisco CA

Insider Stock and Compensation

The Capacity Rating Workshop was really useful. I was new to the prospect research field when I took the workshop, so it helped to demystify capacity ratings for me. The online classroom provided a great forum for interaction with the other participants and for a robust exchange of ideas. Beyond that though, Jen shared a wealth of information and resources about capacity ratings and other important aspects of prospect research. I highly recommend this workshop whether you’re new to the field or have years of experience in our profession.

David Lloyd, Prospect Research Professional, San Francisco, CA

Capacity Rating Workshop

Articles that inspire

Learning Edge